Tuesday, October 16, 2018

Why we need watchdogs to police the digital marketing space

Most conversations that involve digital marketing, and the efforts of accommodation providers and online travel agencies to gain exposure, usually revolve around advertising.

But that’s only half the story, with search engine optimisation still playing a significant role when it comes to how much visibility a brand can get from the ‘ten blue links’ that still populate the Search Engine Results Pages (SERPS) on Google.

A common complaint from accommodation providers is that they can’t compete with keyword buying against the likes of Expedia Group and Booking Holdings, which between them spent upwards of $10 billion during 2017.  But research has shown just how dominant the same intermediaries are in organic search, too.

Hermann Valsson, a former tourism student from the University of Iceland and an IT administrator in the Spanish island of Tenerife, analysed SERPS on Google to see to what extent hotel brands in the region were featuring in organic search on Google.

The answer: very little.

OTAs have a SERPlus

Using the key phrase “hotel tenerife”, Valsson looked at the ten countries sending the most tourists to the popular holiday destination.

Searches on the phrase in the United Kingdom, for example, which accounts for 34% of visitors to Tenerife, had ten out of ten of the organic results coming via online travel agencies, according to the research.

Only searches on the phrase from devices in Sweden and Finland saw any significant visibility for domestic Tenerife-based hotels.

  • UK – ten out of ten links were OTAs
  • Spain – ten out of ten links were OTAs
  • Germany – ten out of ten links were OTAs
  • France – first seven links, then link 10 were OTAs
  • Sweden – first seven links were OTAs
  • Italy – first seven links, then link nine and ten were OTAs
  • Denmark – ten out of ten links were OTAs OTAs
  • Finland – first seven links were OTAs
  • Russia – first six links, then link 8, 9 and 10 were OTAs
  • Ireland – ten out of ten links were OTAs

Valsson claims multiple analyses have shown that some 90 percent of searchers only visited the first page of SERPS, with 37 percent of clicks hitting the first slot, 14 percent to the second and almost ten percent to the third.

He says the analysis is not the first to demonstrate the prowess of intermediaries to dominate SERPS – giving them a sizeable presence when combined with paid for listings.

“The digital footprint just gets better and better for the OTAs, and worse and worse for the hotels, although we are searching for a hotel and NOT for a booking engine,” he claims.

This is just one example, of course, but it is a trend that has been mirrored elsewhere on multiple search terms.

There is no suggestion in the wider world of digital marketing that those who spend heavily on PPC can influence organic search results.

Yet the lack of success with SEO adds another layer of complexity to the already challenging environment that hotels operate in with their digital marketing.

Valsson says: “The fact that OTAs have taken over the organic part of SERPS will change the way that hotels work with their digital marketing. But what can they do – they have lost this digital fight, the OTAs are on top.”

He argues that the situation has become a matter for respective competition authorities to investigate, with high-spenders in travel marketing unable or unwilling to change their tactics.

About Kevin May

Kevin May writes for PhocusWire

Check Also

Sydney’s new cool led by ground-breaking hotels

Not since before the 2000 Olympics has the city seen a fervour of hotel building and renovation - and this time around, the newbies are all decidedly different.

Home invasion: Marriott embraces share economy

Marriott International is further blurring the lines between homeshares and hotels with the announcement it will expand its London homesharing pilot to encompass Paris, Rome and Lisbon.

Magnificent managers mentor to the max..

If your accommodation is looking to improve guest service satisfaction, one of the first steps mid-level managers should do is evaluate how they’re mentoring or developing front-line staff.

One comment

  1. SEO is massively impacted by customer experience – SEO copywriting and technical SEO tactics can only go so far to compete with the fact that OTAs provide a better customer experience.
    Fact is, users want to compare hotels and the easiest way to do that is through an OTA.
    If users don’t want to compare hotels, they’ll search the brand of the hotel they are specifically interested in and if that’s your brand you should rank.
    You don’t need an authority to investigate this (which in my view is throwing a tantrum because a bigger company is kicking your ass in a fair market).
    You need more creative marketing! You’re not going to rank for “Hotel Tenerife” but you might rank for “Hotel with good breakfast in Tenerife”.
    Good keyword research, targeting long tail keywords and online PR are key in competing with OTAs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *